I sat on the couch with a blanket wrapped around my legs, eating Hershey kisses and watching “Seinfeld.” It was nearly 7:50 PM on a Thursday evening and I was supposed to be at a party in Brooklyn at 8. Yet I sat, with no plans to move anytime soon.
My cell phone sat silently on the table beside the pile of Hershey kiss wrappers. I didn’t feel the need to disturb it from its lonely sleep. I probably should have called someone to say I wasn’t on my way, but I was comfortable just as I was, wearing the soccer jersey that belonged to the boy waiting for me at the party.
I wanted to go and see him, I did. But something held me fast to that couch.
We had been dating for barely two weeks, and a few weeks later the summer would be over and with it, our relationship, if it lasted even that long. It was expiration dating in its most basic form, and I was just trying to play by the rules: Number 1: Don’t get attached, and Number 2: When you inevitably do get attached, spend all your energy acting like you’re not.
I wasn’t attached yet, but I was getting uncomfortably close.
I had realized this the previous night at a bar with several of our coworkers. I spotted him from across the room, talking to a girl from our office whom neither us was crazy about. She wasn’t particularly attractive and had a boyfriend anyway who, moreover, was there.
I knew he wasn’t interested in her. And yet I had wanted nothing more than to walk over and put my arms around him, even grab him and kiss him, proclaiming him as my own.
Maybe it was because he looked so cute. Maybe it was the alcohol in me. Perhaps – dare I even think it – I was falling for him. No, that couldn’t be it. It had to be the cuteness factor.
I looked over at the pile of crumpled Hershey kiss wrappers. If I didn’t move now, the pile would only get bigger as the night went on. But if I did go – my phone was ringing and his name was flashing across the front –
“Hello?”
“Hey.” I heard his voice on the other end. “Are you coming?”
* * * *
Run. Run, I said to myself. Get out while you still can. It was three months later, I was back at school, and the same thing was happening all over again. Different guy, same reaction. I realized the guy I was seeing was close to perfect, felt myself getting attached to him, and freaked.
It was Sunday morning and I had just come from having brunch with him. I had pretended to read the newspaper, but actually couldn’t concentrate at all, even on the comics. I just kept looking up at him across the table, wondering if he was feeling the same way I did, hoping he liked me too. But he just sat, wrapped up in his stir fry creation and small talk, seemingly oblivious to my trembling knees and questioning glances.
Back in my room, I had no better luck concentrating on my work than I did on the Sunday Times. After an hour had gone by and only three pages had been turned in my book, my knees shaking more than my eyes were moving across the page, I decided to go back to the cafeteria and attempt to calm myself with food. I wasn’t particularly hungry, but what the hell. Emotional eating. Always a good idea.
For my first breakfast, I’d had oatmeal with cinnamon and raisons, a healthy choice. Now my tray was filled with pancakes and muffins. They didn’t seem to help. Now not only was I upset, but I had eaten too much. Emotional eating. Never a good idea.
I spotted my ex-boyfriend sitting across the room with a friend of his. We had dated freshman year, and every time I felt myself having serious feelings for him, I doubted the strength of his feelings and tried to call it off. But I always called him back, and he always came. Until finally one time he didn’t. I guess I should have realized he was crazy about me too before it was too late.
His friend got up to get more food and I took the opportunity to go over and steal his seat. My ex-boyfriend looked up from his newspaper to see me sitting across from him, my knee still caught in that nervous bounce. “Hey,” he said, his lips slowly forming that familiar smile.
“Hey,” I responded very matter-of-factly. “Listen, I have to talk to you. I’m freaking out about something and I think you’re the only one who can help me.”
“Me? Why?” he answered.
“Because I’ve done it to you before,” I responded.
He smiled. “I’m not having sex with you right now, Liv. I’m eating.”
My eyebrows furrowed and I got up to leave. “What? No! That wasn’t what I was going to ask you.” I tapped him on the head as if to scold him. “I just wanted to talk to you.”
“Okay, we’ll talk. But Justin’s coming back now.” I looked up, saw his friend approaching, and disappeared as fast as I’d arrived.
“He would know what to do,” I thought to myself as I walked away. “He has to know.”
But what was I doing? Relying on an ex to figure out how to save a current relationship? Wasn’t that just a little twisted? I didn’t know what else to do. It’s as if a switch in me flips whenever I realize I’m getting close to someone and I freak out: Does he feel the same way? Or have I been reading the signs completely wrong and making a fool of myself?
The same thing that had gone through my head on that summer night was going through my head now. I was asking myself the same questions and having the very same doubts. But this wasn’t a summer fling – it wasn’t expiration dating. I was with someone who could potentially make me truly happy, so why was I worried about getting attached?
* * * *
I sat in my English professor’s office as she searched for a draft of the above writing. My fingers tapped nervously on her desk. “Alright, I can’t find the copy, but I read it,” she said to me as I fidgeted, anxious more about the subject matter than the writing.
“Did you like it?” I asked, eager for an answer.
She leaned back in her chair and thought for a moment before she replied. “Tell me,” she said. “What are you worried about? What is bothering you so much?”
“I don’t know,” I said. “I don’t know. I’m just…I’m freaking out.” My writing tutorials had become more therapy session than grammatical critique.
“Olivia, listen,” she responded. “You have to calm down. This is crazy. Have some trust in the future! You operate at such a high intensity level that you’re probably freaking the guy out. Just calm down and let it happen!”
But could I? I left my professor’s office that day feeling antsy and frustrated. She was right; I do operate at a ridiculously high intensity level. And not just in relationships, in everything I do. But why should I be the one to change? Then again, why shouldn’t I?
A line from When Harry Met Sally that has always stuck in my head came to mind later that day.
Harry Burns: There are two kinds of women: high maintenance and low maintenance.
Sally Albright: Which one am I?
Harry Burns: You’re the worst kind. You’re high maintenance but you think you’re low maintenance.
Now, perhaps Harry Burns, and even Billy Crystal, believe that there are two kinds of women in this world. Or even three. But let me introduce you to a fourth kind: the high maintenance woman who not only knows she’s high maintenance but is not ashamed of it. Nice to meet you too.
Perhaps I’m crazy. Hell, call me bat-shit crazy. And yes, I freak out about things unnecessarily. But I shouldn’t be led to that point. I shouldn’t have to get to the point in a relationship where I don’t know where the other person stands. I deserve to just fucking know.
People do this all the time. Overanalyze, search for meaning where there probably isn’t any. Wonder what every little interaction signifies. All because we just want to know what the hell is going on. My god, how nice would it be if we were just filled in?
I’m asking this rhetorically because recently I was filled in. In fact, by the same guy I was now freaking out about. He explained everything to me – how he felt, where he stood, what was bothering him. And it was great – I knew what was going on, I didn’t have to wonder what was up when something was up – he just told me. Even if it was stuff I didn’t necessarily want to hear, it was better to know what was going on then to be left wondering. He was straight-forward and honest with me, and it made me feel safe. It made me feel comfortable.
Until he stopped filling me in, stopped telling me what was bothering him. It was clear that there was something bothering him, and not knowing what it was didn’t make me feel safe or comfortable at all. In fact, it made me crazy.
If you analyze the situation mathematically on a communication vs. bat-shit crazy graph, you will see that the levels of bat-shit crazy are kept at bay as long as the communication levels are high. As soon as the communication levels drop, levels of bat-shit crazy soar. We have no idea what’s going on. We start making things up in our heads because we are unsure of the situation. And, undoubtedly, we’re unsure of ourselves. We go, to use another animal adjectival phrase, ape-shit. Therefore, a direct correlation exists between being comfortable in a relationship and being sure of the situation. But are we ever sure?
The truth is, no one ever knows exactly what’s going on. And while some communication is a lot better than none at all, and consistency from someone makes us feel comfortable with them, even a relationship with the most consistent and communicative person can end in a heart beat. Worrying about it only speeds up the process. Trying to be sure of something and letting a situation make us crazy comes through in our actions, body language, and conversation, and ultimately turns off the other person, in effect causing the very thing we were worried about in the first place.
It’s funny that sometimes we need our relationships to go to shit in order to learn anything about ourselves. We learn the best lessons from the relationships we are most invested in, or most hopeful about. And when those fall apart, it’s really not funny at all, it’s just sad. So I think I’ll relax and just let things happen. Not when the next relationship comes around, but right now. I trust in the future. Or, at least, I’m trying to.